More info for the terms: association, cactus, codominant, cool-season, cover, density, fire management, fire severity, fire suppression, fire-return interval, forbs, frequency, fuel, litter, mesic, prescribed fire, presence, ramet, relative dominance, selection, severity, warm-season
FIRE ADAPTATIONS AND PLANT RESPONSE TO FIRE:
Fire adaptations: As of late 2009 there was little information in the available literature on tall dropseed's fire adaptations. Tall dropseed reproduces from tillers as well as seed (see Regeneration Processes). Mississippi dropseed has rhizomes (See Botanical description) that have been described as Âvigorous [37]. Postfire sprouting from tillers or rhizomes would allow tall dropseed to persist and possibly spread in the postfire environment; however, its postfire response likely depends on a number of other factors (see Plant response to fire).
The potential for abundant seed production, seed banking, and favorable conditions for tall dropseed germination and seedling establishment in the postfire environment suggests that it may establish from on-site seed following fire. Fire can be effective in reducing litter, raising soil temperatures [215,237], increasing light levels, releasing nutrients [215], and increasing plant productivity in tallgrass and southern mixed-grass prairies [215,237], all of which favor seedling germination and establishment. However, it is unclear whether and under what conditions tall dropseed seeds survive fire. Tall dropseed seeds germinated from soil samples collected from west-central Iowa prairie sites with a nearly 18-year history of fire management, and from an eastern redcedar woodland with a 10-year history of fire management [194]. No details were provided regarding the type of fire management used, such as season or frequency of burning.
Dispersal by animals may allow for postfire establishment from off-site seed sources; however, this has not been documented in the literature as of late 2009.
Plant response to fire: Postfire responses of tall dropseed documented in the literature are not consistent; it has been observed to increase [27,28,81,84,175], decrease [39,81,84,160,227,231,232], and remain unchanged [82,143,180,193,202] in the postfire environment. Tall dropseed postfire survival, persistence, and spread are likely influenced by a number of interacting factors including fire and fuel characteristics, fire history, site conditions that influence moisture and nutrient availability (e.g., soil type and topography), plant community composition, presence of grazing animals before and after fire, management history, and postfire management. It is not always clear from the available literature which of these factors most strongly influences tall dropseed postfire response in a given situation. However, it appears that tall dropseed is most likely to increase after infrequent fires (fire-return intervals >2 years) in early spring on comparatively mesic sites, or in periods with high precipitation. Tall dropseed may have greater tolerance of annual burning in grazed areas.
Although several studies include information on tall dropseed's response to fire, none are focused exclusively on tall dropseed, and individual studies are limited in various ways. Limitations include varying amounts of information on confounding factors, few replicates or controls, small sample sizes, differences in timing of vegetation sampling relative to fires, comparison of multiple simultaneous treatments, and/or anecdotal evidence. Many studies report responses of a group of species that included tall dropseed [7,21,98,149], such as warm-season and/or perennial grasses [47,66,67,89,217] or midgrasses [226,229]. Results from 3 of these studies [149,217,229] are included in the discussion below. Studies that investigate community-level responses to fire in areas where tall dropseed occurs include Collins and Smith [40], Dai and others [47], Fuhlendorf and Engle [77] and/or Risser and Parton [189]. Community-level responses from these studies are not discussed in this review.
Fire frequency: Single fires apparently have little impact on tall dropseed abundance. On a pasture in the Edwards Plateau near Johnson City, Texas, tall dropseed cover on experimental plots burned on 25 August or 28 October of 2004 did not differ significantly (P>0.05) from each other orfrom unburned plots a year later [202]. On a central Oklahoma rangeland, average tall dropseed frequency in December did not differ significantly (P>0.05) on unburned sites and sites burned in late March [180]. In Pinchot's juniper-dominated rangelands of northwestern Texas, frequency of tall dropseed did not differ significantly (P>0.05) between a site burned 4 years previously in spring, a site burned 8 years previously in spring, and an unburned control site [143].In one Konza prairie study differences in stem density of tall dropseed on sites burned a few months, 1, and 3 years previously were not significant [54]. On Konza prairie sites burned in late April 1981 or early May 1982, tall dropseed flower stalk density and height at the end of the growing season of the fire year were not significantly different from unburned sites. However, biomass on unburned sites was lower than on burned sites in both 1981 and 1982. Tall dropseed total oven-dried mass was 7.2 g/m² and 10.0 g/m² on burned sites, and 2.7 g/m² and 1.8 g/m² on unburned sites in 1981 and 1982, respectively. The combined aboveground biomass of tall dropseed, big bluestem, indiangrass, little bluestem, sideoats grama, and switchgrass was significantly (P<0.01) greater on burned than unburned sites in both years [110]. In tallgrass prairie near Stillwater, Oklahoma, tall dropseed phenological development in May, June, or July did not differ significantly between control plots and plots treated with herbicide and burned in late spring. Comparisons between treated and control plots were not made in August or September [24].
Repeated fires at intervals greater than 1 year also seem to have little impact on talldropseed. In pastures of southern Iowa, tall dropseed showed no significant changes in biomass or relative shoot frequency up to a year following burning treatments in March or April. This included plots burned twice in 3 years [193]. On Kansas prairie sites that had been burned 4 times in 6 years, tall dropseed frequency ranged from 50.0% to 75.0% and biomass ranged from 14.9 to 29.7 g/m² in August [177] (see Soils/topography for details). On the Konza Prairie, tall dropseed was not noticeably impacted by spring burning every 4 years [82] and was a subdominant on a winter-grazed area north of Manhattan, Kansas, burned 2 to 3 times in 10 years [174]. Tall dropseed was the only native grass in a southwestern Minnesota old field burned every 3 to 4 years over a period of about 18 years [254]. In contrast, in mixed-grass or tallgrass prairie in Iowa, tall dropseed did not occur on plots that were burned 1 to 3 times in 8 years or on grazed-and-burned plots, despite occurring at low frequency on grazed-only plots [34].
Annual burning: Although tall dropseed occurs in some annually burned prairies, most evidence suggests that tall dropseed abundance may be lower on annually burned sites. This may not be the case in grazed areas (See Interactions between fire and grazing), and the effects of annual burning likely depend on several other factors including fire season, species composition, and prefire and postfire precipitation. In tallgrass prairie sites in central Oklahoma, cover of tall dropseed in June ranged from 12.9% to 17.4% on unburned sites compared to 3.7% to 6.1% on sites burned in annually April. The declines in tall dropseed cover following the 2nd and 3rd annual burns on this site were significant (P<0.05). Grazing occurred on a subset of both the burned and unburned sites but did not have a significant influence on tall dropseed's response to fire [39]. Although variable over the course of a 5-year study near Stillwater, Oklahoma, tall dropseed frequency on a site that was burned every spring from 1984 to 1988 was significantly (P<0.05) lower in 3 of 4 summers following the thirdannual burn compared to the July after the second burn [92]. Towne and Kemp [232] found tall dropseed cover was significantly lower after 8 years of annual burning than following the first burn on the Konza prairie, regardless of season of burning or topographic position, while frequency was significantly higher on sites burned annually in winter. Perhaps seedling establishment increased with annual burning in February, while vigor of sprouters was reduced with annual burning regardless of season.
Cover*/frequency (%) of tall dropseed in 2001, following 8 years of annual burning, in 3 different seasons and 2 topographic positions [232]. Burn season Late November Mid-February Late April Uplands 0.8/85 2.0/95+ 0.9/75 Lowlands 4.8/97.5 2.5/97.5+ 0.9/90 *All cover values are significantly (P<0.05) lower than tall dropseed cover following the first burn.
+ indicates a significant increases in tall dropseed frequency between 1994 and 2001
Gibson and Hulbert [86] found a weak but positive association between tall dropseed cover and time since fire on the Konza prairie. Other studies at Konza prairie found similar results. Tall dropseed was never a dominant species on annually burned sites. It occurred as a codominant less often on plots burned annually for at least 5 yearsthan on plots that had not been burned in 3 years [88]. Tall dropseed did not occur on a site burned in spring for 4 consecutive years but comprised 5% of the relative cover on a site burned 2 years previously [78]. No tall dropseed seeds germinated from soil samples collected from a Konza prairie watershed burned annually in April, an average of 0.2 tall dropseed seedlings emerged from 1,352-cm² soil samples collected from a watershed that had been burned from 2 to 6 years previously, and an average of 1.3 tall dropseed seedlings emerged from 1,352-cm² soil samples collected from a watershed that had not been burned in about 12 years. Tall dropseed cover was less than 5% on all of these sites and may have been absent from some sites [1]. At the end of the 2000 growing season, no tall dropseed seedlings were observed on a plot burned annually since 1996, while an average of about 0.5 tall dropseed seedling/m² occurred on a plot last burned in 1991. Tall dropseed ramet density was similar on annually and infrequently burned plots [20].
In some cases, tall dropseed has greater occurrence on annually burned sites than less frequently burned areas. Tall dropseed was referred to as an important species of annually burned sites on the Oklahoma Agricultural Experiment Station Research Range near Stillwater, Oklahoma [150] and was 1 of the 12 most common species on annually burned sites in the Konza prairie [124]. In the Konza prairie, tall dropseed cover ranged from 5% to 11% on sites burned every 1 or 2 years, while cover in areas burned 3 or more years apart ranged from 1% to 5% [240]. Additional data from the Konza prairie suggests that tall dropseed cover and frequency were higher on sites burned annually in November and March than on sites burned annually in late April, sites burned every 2 years, or unburned sites; however, no statistical comparisons were made. This report includes cover and frequency data from areas with varied fire frequencies, seasons of annual fires, and soil characteristics. Data are presented in the table below and are referred to in other portions of this review [84]:
Maximum percent cover/percent frequency of tall dropseed measured from late spring to late summer on plots with different soil types and burning treatments in Konza prairie. The number of replications for each treatment is in parentheses [84]. Fire frequency Fire season (month) Site Characteristics Silty clay soils on foot slopes Cherty silt soils on upper rim of slopes Annual November 13/72 (2) 24/100 (1) March 25/95 (2) 22/90 (1) Late April 0.2/10 (3) 5.5/28 (3) 2-year interval April 0.9/17 (3) 0.2/7 (3) 4-year interval April 15/65 (2) 2.2/28 (2) Unburned N/A 3.0/25 (2) 0.7/15 (3)
Fire Season: Although responses are variable, fires in the early spring may benefit tall dropseed, while fires following emergence of tall dropseed in late spring (see Seasonal development) may be detrimental. As of late 2009, little information is available on tall dropseed’s response to summer [81,229] or autumn fires. Limited data suggest tall dropseed response to autumn fire is variable. Impacts of winter fires on tall dropseed are variable but generally small [28,81,175,232].
Tall dropseed generally responds positively or neutrally to early- and mid-spring burning [81,110,175,180], with neutral or negative responses more likely following late-spring burning [84,232,233]. One possible explanation for this trend is that the reduction of mulch by fire in early spring results in warmer soils and greater grass production earlier in the year [52]. Additionally, fires in late spring may be more likely to damage tall dropseed than fire in other seasons, because it is typically dormant in early spring and emerges in mid to late spring (see Seasonal development).
Some studies show no change [110,175,180] or an increased abundance [81,110] of tall dropseed after early spring fires, and some show differences in tall dropseed response to early and late spring fires [84,233]. The average frequency of tall dropseed on a central Oklahoma rangeland was similar (P=0.54) on plots burned in late March and unburned plots [180]. Data from the Konza prairie suggest that tall dropseed had the highest cover and frequency on sites burned annually in March and November and the lowest cover and frequency on unburned sites and those burned annually in late April (Gibson [84]). On a south-central Iowa site dominated by smooth brome (Bromus inermis), Kentucky bluegrass, and talldropseed, tall dropseed increases in cover and frequency following April fires were significant (P<0.05) and persistent, with effects present over 3 years following the first burn treatment. See the table below for values associated with varioustreatments [81]. Tall dropseed was included with several perennial grasses that as a group had significantly (P<0.05) higher percent composition based on cover in unburned, winter burned, and early spring burned than in mid-spring burned areas in tallgrass prairie north of Manhattan, Kansas. These grasses comprised the smallest percentage of the vegetation on late-spring burned plots, significantly (P<0.05) less than plots burned in any other season [233]. Similarly, compared to burning in late March and late April, burning in mid-May reduced the standing crop of Sporobolus species in June on a tallgrass prairie site in Nebraska [156].
Cover/frequency (%) of tall dropseed on a site in south-central Iowa before, during, and after burning in various seasons. Different letters in the same row indicate significant differences (P<0.05) in cover; + or - indicates the direction of a significant change from preburn frequency [81]. Month of Burn Sampling period August 1972 (preburn) August 1973** August 1974*** August 1975 August 1976 February 2/19 11/25 20/38 21/25 23/25 April 7a/25 55b/100+ 77c/100+ 71c/100+ 87c/100+ June 48/88 15/50- 26/63* 24/56 30/50 September 27a/44 0b/6** 0b/0- *** 0b/0- 5b/13 Control 0/0 6/13 8/25 6/19 20/31 *Burning was not completed due to insufficient fuels
**First postfire growing season for all treatments except September burns; preburn for September treatments
***Second postfire growing season for all treatments except September burns; first postfire growing season for September treatments
Response of tall dropseed to differences in timing of fire is likely to vary among sites and years, and may not follow the expected trend. For example, the relative basal cover comprised of tall dropseed on moderately grazed upland range and limestone breaks sites at the Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station were similar on unburned sites and those burned in early spring, mid-spring,and late spring [152]. In an upland tallgrass prairie near Grand Forks, North Dakota, May burning resulted in an increase in tall dropseed frequency from 40% the year before burning to 100% the following August. On unburned upland sites tall dropseed declined [95].
Few data are available regarding tall dropseed's response to summer fires. Tall dropseed frequency significantly declined 2 months following June fires in south-central Iowa. See the table based on data from George and others [81] for more detail. As a group, perennial warm-season midgrasses, including tall dropseed, declined following summer fires in mesquite-grassland in Texas, although the difference was not significant in 2 of the 3 years investigated and only marginally so (P<0.06) in the 3rd [229].
Although tall dropseed has been considered vulnerable to autumn fires[37,232], data suggest variable responses. Tall dropseed declined following annual autumn burning in the Konza prairie (Towne and Kemp [232]).In south-central Iowa, tall dropseed declined before autumn burning was implemented. Despite significant tall dropseed increases on spring-burned sites, tall dropseed cover remained low and did not recover on autumn-burned sites (George and others [81]). However, tall dropseed abundance was greater on autumn-burned sites than unburned sites in the Konza prairie (Gibson [84]) and in southTexas brush ranges [28] (see below).
Winter fires generally have small and/or short-term impacts on tall dropseed. On the Konza prairie tall dropseed cover declined significantly (P<0.05) following annual fires on upland and lowland sites burned either in winter, late autumn, or mid-spring. However, tall dropseed frequency increased significantly on both lowland and upland sites burned in winter. See the data table from Towne and KempÂs [232] study for details. On an abandoned field where tall dropseed occurred with prairie threeawn in eastern Kansas, percent basal cover of tall dropseed on 4 August 1975 was 6.7% on the unburned plots, 28.3% in the plots burned 13 December 1974, and 10% each in the plots burned 9 January, 12 February, and 5 March 1975. This was a significant (P<0.05) difference between treatments. The authors suggest that reductions in prairie threeawn seedlings that occurred with December burning resulted in increases in tall dropseed on those plots [175]. In south Texas brush ranges, tall dropseed herbage production in August of 1967 was 36 lbs/acre on control plots, 87 lbs/acre in areas burned in September of 1965, 33 lbs/acre in areas burned in December 1966, and 42 lbs/acre in areas burned in both seasons [28]. Tall dropseed occurrence was slightly higher in Texas live oak plots burned in February compared to unburned plots. For details of the site conditions and fire characteristics see this study's FEIS Research Project Summary [115]. On a south-central Iowa site dominated by smooth brome, Kentucky bluegrass, and tall dropseed, burning in February did not have a significant impact on tall dropseed cover or frequency (George and others [81]). The percentage of herbaceous perennial biomass comprised of tall dropseed declined significantly (P<0.05) from 11% to 6% following late-winter burning in mesquite/mixed-grass rangelands in north-central Texas. However, differences in the percent composition of tall dropseed on these sites were not significant a year later [227]. Five years following implementation of treatments in Blackland prairie in Texas, tall dropseed was common in all treatments, including a plot experimentally burned in February [13]. Tall dropseed was included with several perennial grasses that as a group had significantly (P<0.05) higher percent cover (see above) in unburned, winter burned, and early spring burned than in mid-spring burned areas [233].
Species composition: Tall dropseedÂs response to fire may be influenced by a combination of species composition and timing of fire. For example, spring fires in grasslands at a time when warm-season species are dormant and cool-season species are growing is generally thought to reduce the competitive ability of cool-season grasses compared to warm-season grasses [18,109,148,199,237]. According to a review of tallgrass prairie ecology, frequent spring fires result in increased dominance of warm-season, C4 grasses while summer fires increase abundance of cool-season species [215]. Tall dropseed followed this trend on a site in south-central Iowa where it was a codominant with the nonnative, cool-season grasses smooth brome and Kentucky bluegrass. Tall dropseed cover significantly (P<0.05) increased following April fires in 2 consecutive years, and decreased on plots burned in September. Although the decrease occurred before the first September fire, tall dropseed cover and frequency remained low following 2 consecutive September fires [81] (see table for details). However, there are exceptions to this trend. For instance, an early spring fire in an Iowa pasture with only a small proportion of warm-season grasses and low amounts of relatively green fuels did not result in increases of warm-season species [193]. The ratio of C4 to C3 grasses increased after spring fires in lowland areas of a South Dakota mixed-grass prairie community, but not in upland areas [216].
Effects of fire on tall dropseed in woodland and savanna communities are mixed. In Texas live oak vegetation units burned in February, tall dropseed relative dominance and frequency were slightly greater on burned than unburned plots. Statistical comparisons were not made. See the Research Project Summary for details [115]. In a north-central Texas mesquite/mixed-grass rangeland, an increase in herbaceous species despite burning in summer and increased herbivory in burned areas was attributed to reduction of woody plants and cactus. However,warm-season midgrasses as a group did not follow this trend [229]. Tall dropseed dominance and frequency were similar in burned and control post oak vegetation [115]. Tall dropseed exhibited a short-term decline in biomass following late winter burning in mesquite-mixed grass rangelands in north-central Texas. The percentage of perennial biomass comprised of tall dropseed declined significantly (P<0.05) from 11% to 6% following winter burning. Within 1 year, differences on the 2 sites were not significant [227]. The only occurrence of tall dropseed within a ponderosa pine woodland was reported 2 years after a severe fire killed of much of the overstory vegetation [136].
Precipitation: Precipitation is likely influences tall dropseed's postfire response due to increased moisture stress after fire (review [215]). Fire reduced the mulch layer in tallgrass prairies of Nebraska [149] and soil moisture in bluestem range in Kansas [152]. Fires in prairies during periods of drought tend to be of greater severity [215]. Generally, tufted species such as tall dropseed are more susceptible to damage from fire when conditions are dry [156].
Tall dropseed generally seems to respond positively to fires during periods of adequate precipitation [18,182,229,237,256,257] and negatively to fires during dry periods or drought [149,237,257]. Two similar reviews note that tall dropseed may exhibit strong positive responses to fire when there is adequate moisture, and that fire during [257] or following [237] dry years negatively affects at least 1 variety of tall dropseed [237,257]. Rasmussen and others [182] assert that yield of tall dropseed increased following fires in wet years. In a southwestern Minnesota old field, tall dropseed cover during the summer increased from 4.2% to 11.3% following burning in the wet spring of 1984 but did not change substantially following burning in the comparatively dry spring of 1983 [18]. During a dry period, the standing crop of Sporobolus species, including tall dropseed, was 1,308 kg/ha on unburned and fertilized areas compared to 617 kg/ha on burned and fertilized areas of a tallgrass prairie site in Nebraska [149]. Tall dropseed production was 53% greater (P<0.05) on a pasture burned in March of a wet year compared to an unburned mixed-grass pasture with Ashe juniper and oaks in Texas. Tall dropseed production exhibited a smaller, but also significant (P<0.05), increase on a site in this area burned in March of a dry year (24%). This site was in a lowland that received runoff water from storms [256]. One exception to this pattern occurred on a site near Stillwater, Oklahoma, that was burned annually in March or April since 1984: Tall dropseed frequency increased during the 1988 growing season, which had below-average precipitation. However, annual precipitation was above-average during the study period as a whole [92].
Positive responses to burning and tolerance of frequent fire may be more likely in moist tallgrass prairies of the eastern Great Plains compared to drier mixed-grass and short-grass prairies of the western Great Plains. A review notes that increases in herbage yield following burning are often reported from more humid prairies such as those in Wisconsin, Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, eastern Kansas, and eastern Oklahoma, while studies in western areas of Kansas, South Dakota, and North Dakota have reported reductions in yield after burning [130]. To maintain or improve grass production, 2 similar reviews recommend longer fire-return intervals for drier areas of the Great Plains than for more mesic areas [237,257] (see Fire Management Considerations for details). The drier mixed-grass and short-grass prairie zones may also be more likely to experience reduced productivity and longer recovery times if burned during periods of drought.
Soil/topography: Sometimes tall dropseed’s response to fire differs on sites with differing soil characteristics. In tallgrass prairies of the Konza prairie, tall dropseed's frequency and cover on sites with the same FIRE REGIMES were usually similar despite differing soil type. However, on sites burned in early April at 4-year intervals, tall dropseed was more common on silty clay soils on foot slopes compared to cherty silt soils on the upper rim of slopes. The opposite trend was observed on these soil types on plots burned annually in late April [84] (see table above). On a bluestem range site in Kansas, tall dropseed comprised similar proportions of the vegetation on claypan sites with comparatively low moisture availability and on limestone breaks and upland range sites that were either unburned, burned in early spring, or burned in mid-spring. However, on sites burned in late spring tall dropseed comprised from 4.9% to 7.9% of the vegetation on claypan sites compared to 0% to 3.9% of the vegetation on limestone breaks and upland range sites [152]. Edaphic factors and management history were more influential than fire in determining plant species composition of an early-successional Oklahoma prairie [64]. Conflicting results regarding the effects of soil depth on tall dropseed response to fire have been reported. On the Konza prairie, tall dropseed stem density was generally higher on a site with shallow soil (0-415 stems/m²) in the first 3 postfire years than on a site with deep soil (5-90 stems/m²) [54]. Frequency of tall dropseed in May, June, and August was greater on sites with deep siltloam than on a site with a comparatively shallow silt loam in Saline, Kansas, following 4 burns in 6 years, the most recent the March before sampling. Phytomass was similar on the 2 sites in May and June, but in August tall dropseed phytomass on the site with deep soil was twice that on the site with comparatively shallow soil [177]:
Average phytomass (SE) and frequency of tall dropseed on sites in Saline County, Kansas with differing soil depths that had been burned 4 times in 6 years, the most recent the previous March [177] Month Corner Site
(comparatively shallow silt loam) Hill Site
(deep silt loam) Phytomass (g/m²) Frequency (%) Phytomass (g/m²) Frequency (%)
May
4.7 (3.9) 33.3 3.2 (1.5) 58.3 June 13.2 (8.0) 16.7 12.0 (4.8) 66.7 August 14.9 (9.6) 50.0 29.7 (10.2) 75.0
Limited evidence suggests fire may be more damaging to tall dropseed in lowlands than in uplands. Frequency of tall dropseed was 100% in upslope areas of the Konza prairie, 70% at the bottom of slopes, and 0% in lowlands burned annually in March [85]. In mixed-grass prairie of southern Nebraska, relative abundance of tall dropseed differed among sites following reduced grazing and 9 prescribed fires that were conducted over a 17-year period. See the table below for details [160]. In upland tallgrass prairie near Grand Forks, North Dakota, tall dropseed frequency increased from 40% the year before fire to 100% the August after a May fire, while on unburned upland sites tall dropseed declined over this period. On a lowland site in this area, tall dropseed declined from 20% to 0% after a May fire. Tall dropseed did not occur on an unburned lowland before or after fire [95]. Although rarely a codominant on annually burnedplots in the Konza prairie, tall dropseed occurred as a codominant on annually burned lowlands slightly more often than on annually burned uplands [88].
Percentage of total vascular plant biomass comprised of tall dropseed in 1976 and 1992 in a mixed-prairie of southern Nebraska. Management during this 17-year period included reduced grazing intensity and 9 prescribed fires [160]. Year All sites Silty lowland Shallow, limy upland Silty Upland 1976 7.83 15.09 4.31* 7.19 1992 9.91 0.0 1.93* 15.04 *difference significant (P<0.05) between years
Fuel Condition: Moist or green fuels on a site may result in fires that are not severe enough to benefit warm-season grasses. For example, in cool-season grasslands of southern Iowa with a comparatively high proportion of green biomass, burning in March did not alter biomass of cool- or warm-season grasses, including tall dropseed. The lack of litter on this site due to overgrazing also contributed to low fire severity [193]. On a site with a high water table in southwestern Minnesota, prescribed fire in May did not stimulate warm-season species or injure cool-season species and brush. Due to the occurrence of unburned mulch, cool-season grasses remained vigorous [18].
Fire may be more severe and more likely to negatively impact tall dropseed when tufts have substantial amounts of accumulated, dry litter [45]. Dry conditions could exacerbate this risk to tufted species. Mitchell and others [156] suggest that litter accumulation in prairie dropseed tussocks contributed to the decline of Sporobolus species following late-spring burning in tallgrass prairies of eastern Nebraska.
For details regarding the fuel characteristics of tall dropseed and its associated communities and the relationship between fuel accumulation and tall dropseed's occurrence in unburned areas, see Fuels.
Interactions between fire and grazing: Recently burned areas are often selected by grazing animals [77,96]. Recently burned areas were strongly selected for grazing in spring and summer by bison in the Konza prairie [240] and northeastern Oklahoma [96]. Selection of graminiods in burned areas resulted in an increase in forbs, with native warm-season grasses regaining dominance several years after fires in northeastern Oklahoma [96] and in 2 to 3 years after fire in north-central Oklahoma [77]. No significant interaction of fire and grazing was observed in a central Oklahoma study [39].
Tall dropseed may have greater tolerance of annual burning on sites that are grazed. On the Konza prairie, tall dropseed percent cover declined significantly (P<0.01) from 1995 to 2004 on an annually burned site that was not grazed, while declines in percent cover on annually burned sites that were grazed by bison or cattle were not significant [231]. In another Konza prairie study, tall dropseed cover on annually burned sitesthat were grazed was 4.5% compared to 0.38% in annually burned sites along theedge of bison wallows. On grazed sites with a 4-year fire-return interval, cover was 3.75%, while cover on the edge of bison wallows was 4.13%. These differences were not significant [234]. Tall dropseed cover on annually burned uplands grazed by bison was 15.3%, significantly (P<0.01) more than the 6.4% cover in ungrazed, annually burned areas of the Konza prairie. Occurrence of grazing had little impact on tall dropseed cover in areas burned every 4 years, with grazed areas having 8.7% tall dropseed cover and ungrazed areas having 8.1% cover [100]. However, in central Oklahoma, burning in mid-April had greater impacts on cover of tall dropseed than grazing (see Annual burning), and grazed-and-burned plots had only slightly higher cover of tall dropseed than burn-only plots [39]. On 12 mixed-grass and tallgrass prairie plots in Plymouth County, Iowa, tall dropseed occurred on 4 of 192 grazed-only quadrats and none of the quadrats that were grazed and burned 1 to 3 times in 8 years [34].
Tall dropseed may respond negatively to overgrazing in areas protected from fire. In an Ashe juniper community in Texas, tall dropseed was less abundant on "overgrazed" sites than "properly grazed" sites and less abundant on unburned sites than sites that had been burned 4 years previously. Tall dropseed comprised 21.4% of the herbaceous cover of a properly grazed site burned 4 years previously. On an overgrazed site burned 4 years previously tall dropseed comprised 5.3% of the herbaceous cover. Tall dropseed comprised 13.7% of the herbaceous cover on a properly grazed range site burned 17 years previously and was absent on an overgrazed range site burned 43 years previously [113]. According to a description of the cross timbers community type in Texas, woody species are promoted by overgrazing and fire suppression (see FIRE REGIMES); the rate of encroachment into open areas, where tall dropseed is likely to occur, is much faster in overgrazed areas [209]. Overgrazing may be especially damaging on sites burned during periods of drought. Declines in desirable species were long-lasting on a grazed site in the Kansas Flint Hills burned during spring drought [152].
Interactions with other management activities: Management history or concurrent management efforts in an area are likely to influence how tall dropseed responds to fire. For instance, declines in tall dropseed following burning in spring, summer, or fall on a tallgrass prairie site near Omaha, Nebraska, may have been influenced by the cessation of a 20-year mowing regime as well as a response to fire [30]. Tall dropseed comprised an average of 2% of the biomass of vegetation on unburned sites, and 5% of the biomass of burned sites in a study of the impact of various mechanical treatments and fire in a honey mesquite community of south Texas. This difference was considered significant (P<0.05). The increases in tall dropseed were greater on sites that had been burned following shredding, chopping, or scalpingthan on sites where these treatments occurred without burning [27]. On tallgrass prairie plots in Nebraska, occurrence of tall dropseed was lower on burned and fertilized plots than on unburned and fertilized plots [149]. On a central Oklahoma site grazed by sheep, burned and fertilized plots had lower occurrence of tall dropseed than plots that were unburned and fertilized or those that were burned and not fertilized [180]. Species composition of an early-successional tallgrass prairie in Oklahoma was more strongly influenced by land use history and edaphic factors than by fire disturbance [64].